Solution: (b) (Only Options 2 and 3 are CORRECT.)
Difficulty Level: Medium
Micro Topic: Joint sitting of Parliament
Solving Strategy: Requires factual knowledge to solve the question.
Joint sitting is an extraordinary mechanism provided by the Constitution to resolve a deadlock between the two Houses of Parliament over the passage of a bill. A joint sitting of Parliament under Article 108 can be summoned only for Ordinary Bills and Financial Bills (excluding Money Bills) in case of a deadlock, and cannot be convened for Money Bills or Constitutional Amendment Bills.
Option 1 is INCORRECT. Any bill that seeks to increase or modify taxation falls under the definition of a Money Bill as per Article 110. Money Bills cannot be taken up in a joint sitting; they must be passed by the Lok Sabha, and the Rajya Sabha can only make recommendations.
Option 2 is CORRECT. The Citizenship Act is a regular legislative law, and any amendment to it is introduced as an Ordinary Bill. Since it does not amend the Constitution or involve financial matters requiring a Money Bill, it can be referred to a joint sitting in case of a deadlock between the two Houses.
Option 3 is CORRECT. The creation of the All-India Judicial Service, is not a Constitutional Amendment Bill. Under Article 312, the process is initiated by the Rajya Sabha, which must pass a resolution by a two-thirds majority declaring the service necessary in the national interest. Following this, Parliament enacts the law through an Ordinary Bill passed by a simple majority in both Houses. Since the law is ordinary in nature, it is eligible for a joint sitting of Parliament to resolve any deadlock between the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha.
Option 4 is INCORRECT. The composition and functioning of the GST Council are defined under Article 279A, a constitutional provision. Any bill seeking to alter it is therefore a Constitutional Amendment Bill, which requires separate approval by both Houses. As a result, it is not eligible for a joint sitting.
Source:
Indian Polity by M. Laxmikanth, Sixth Edition, Chapter 22, Page No: 22.24
https://www.constitutionofindia.net/articles/article-312-all-india-services/
.
.
.
Fortune IAS Academy is the ????????. ???? ???????????? ???????????????????????????? ???????? ???????????????????????? with 5????????+ success stories. The main pillar of strength of the academy is ???????????????????????????????????????????? ???????????????????????????? who have a fan base among the student community because of their top-notch classes.
The faculty pool is ably supported by a pool of ???????????????????????????? ???????????? ???????????????? ???????????????????????????????????????? ???????????????????????????????????? ???????? ???????????????????????????????? and tailor the study plan according to the strengths and weaknesses of the student. This ensures that even a student without much prior knowledge about the examination is able to succeed at it. Also, the mentors often help the students to overcome the emotional challenges and self-doubts that creep in during the preparation stage.
A ???????????????????????????????? ???????????????????????????????????? is ensured through peer interactions, reading room facilities, daily tests and updated study material. ????
For more information about admissions at Fortune IAS Academy in online or offline mode please call us at 9495015888. Alternatively please fill up the following form so that an academic counsellor can reach out to you :
https://www.fortuneias.com/pcm
To get a glimpse of 10 pillars of Fortune's Prelims cum Mains Course, Click the link below:
https://youtu.be/Fj35qz0Ak_k
For daily current affairs updates and other civil service related news join our UPSC community at https://t.me/fortuneias.
.
.
UPSC Toppers from Kerala - Fortune IAS Academy
#fortuneias #upsctopper #upscexam #upsctoppers #keralaias #upscexam #upscresults #ias #civilservices #ips #keralatopper #keralaresults #prelims #upscprelims #upscmodelquestions #upscinterview #keralasbestiasacademy #no1iasacademy #envirinment #ecology
.
.
For Enquiries, Please Contact us:
Phone: 9495015888, 8138940888
Email: [email protected]
Web: www.fortuneias.com
Join our telegram channel for free study materials - https://t.me/fortuneias
Difficulty Level: Medium
Micro Topic: Joint sitting of Parliament
Solving Strategy: Requires factual knowledge to solve the question.
Joint sitting is an extraordinary mechanism provided by the Constitution to resolve a deadlock between the two Houses of Parliament over the passage of a bill. A joint sitting of Parliament under Article 108 can be summoned only for Ordinary Bills and Financial Bills (excluding Money Bills) in case of a deadlock, and cannot be convened for Money Bills or Constitutional Amendment Bills.
Option 1 is INCORRECT. Any bill that seeks to increase or modify taxation falls under the definition of a Money Bill as per Article 110. Money Bills cannot be taken up in a joint sitting; they must be passed by the Lok Sabha, and the Rajya Sabha can only make recommendations.
Option 2 is CORRECT. The Citizenship Act is a regular legislative law, and any amendment to it is introduced as an Ordinary Bill. Since it does not amend the Constitution or involve financial matters requiring a Money Bill, it can be referred to a joint sitting in case of a deadlock between the two Houses.
Option 3 is CORRECT. The creation of the All-India Judicial Service, is not a Constitutional Amendment Bill. Under Article 312, the process is initiated by the Rajya Sabha, which must pass a resolution by a two-thirds majority declaring the service necessary in the national interest. Following this, Parliament enacts the law through an Ordinary Bill passed by a simple majority in both Houses. Since the law is ordinary in nature, it is eligible for a joint sitting of Parliament to resolve any deadlock between the Lok Sabha and the Rajya Sabha.
Option 4 is INCORRECT. The composition and functioning of the GST Council are defined under Article 279A, a constitutional provision. Any bill seeking to alter it is therefore a Constitutional Amendment Bill, which requires separate approval by both Houses. As a result, it is not eligible for a joint sitting.
Source:
Indian Polity by M. Laxmikanth, Sixth Edition, Chapter 22, Page No: 22.24
https://www.constitutionofindia.net/articles/article-312-all-india-services/
.
.
.
Fortune IAS Academy is the ????????. ???? ???????????? ???????????????????????????? ???????? ???????????????????????? with 5????????+ success stories. The main pillar of strength of the academy is ???????????????????????????????????????????? ???????????????????????????? who have a fan base among the student community because of their top-notch classes.
The faculty pool is ably supported by a pool of ???????????????????????????? ???????????? ???????????????? ???????????????????????????????????????? ???????????????????????????????????? ???????? ???????????????????????????????? and tailor the study plan according to the strengths and weaknesses of the student. This ensures that even a student without much prior knowledge about the examination is able to succeed at it. Also, the mentors often help the students to overcome the emotional challenges and self-doubts that creep in during the preparation stage.
A ???????????????????????????????? ???????????????????????????????????? is ensured through peer interactions, reading room facilities, daily tests and updated study material. ????
For more information about admissions at Fortune IAS Academy in online or offline mode please call us at 9495015888. Alternatively please fill up the following form so that an academic counsellor can reach out to you :
https://www.fortuneias.com/pcm
To get a glimpse of 10 pillars of Fortune's Prelims cum Mains Course, Click the link below:
https://youtu.be/Fj35qz0Ak_k
For daily current affairs updates and other civil service related news join our UPSC community at https://t.me/fortuneias.
.
.
UPSC Toppers from Kerala - Fortune IAS Academy
#fortuneias #upsctopper #upscexam #upsctoppers #keralaias #upscexam #upscresults #ias #civilservices #ips #keralatopper #keralaresults #prelims #upscprelims #upscmodelquestions #upscinterview #keralasbestiasacademy #no1iasacademy #envirinment #ecology
.
.
For Enquiries, Please Contact us:
Phone: 9495015888, 8138940888
Email: [email protected]
Web: www.fortuneias.com
Join our telegram channel for free study materials - https://t.me/fortuneias
- Category
- Try Not To Cum
- Tags
- UPSC, ias, ips
Commenting disabled.
